Archive for the 'Immigration & Refugees' Category

Cutting edge Social Medicine 2011: Resident Projects from the RPSM

Add a comment

What is the cutting edge in Social Medicine in 2011, at least in the Bronx?

The 18 social medicine projects completed by the 2011 graduates of Residency Program in  Social Medicine offer one perspective.  These projects cover a wide variety of topics; three were conducted internationally (Quito Ecuador;  Andhra Pradesh, India; and Rwanda). Among the questions addressed were:

1) Are medical schools and residency programs accountable to the broader society?

2) Does the promotion of Zumba dance in the clinic  improve the health of diabetics?

3)  What are the barriers to reproductive health care among homeless adolescents living in shelters?

4) What is a social medicine doctor?

The abstracts published below represent work by residents in Social Pediatrics, Family Medicine, and Social Internal Medicine/Primary Care. The actual presentations were made during Social Medicine Rounds on May 24, May 31 and June 7, 2011.

Molly Broder, MD, Laura Polizzi, MD, MPH & Ravi Saksena, MD
Assessing Sources and Knowledge of Reproductive Health in 14-21 year-olds in the Bronx

 The objectives of this study are to obtain information about where teenagers receive their information about sexual health topics, to obtain information about the use of the internet/social networking, and to evaluate adolescent knowledge concerning reproductive health. Male and female adolescents between the ages of 14 and 21 were recruited from two urban clinics in the Bronx. They were asked to complete an anonymous survey which included basic demographic information, internet availability, a knowledge assessment, and questions assessing sources of information and their usefulness. Participants were also asked specifics about websites/social networking resources utilized. Responses to survey questions were tabulated in Excel and descriptive statistics were calculated.

One-hundred and eighty-nine adolescents were surveyed during their clinic visits. The median percent correct on knowledge questions was 64.7%. The most common sources were medical professionals (93%), mothers (85%), friends (86%) and the internet (83%). Information provided by medical professionals was seen as the most useful (92%) followed by mom (81%), boy/girlfriend (79%) and the internet (73%). The most common websites used were Google (74%), Yahoo (26%), and Wikipedia (26%). The top four search terms were sex, condoms, birth control, and HIV.

Elizabeth N. Alt, MD, MPH
Implementing Group well child visits as part of a Patient Centered Medical Home at the Family Health Center
 
Traditionally well-child care occurs with individual providers, either family physicians or pediatricians. Studies suggest that group visits with patients in certain chronic disease management and prenatal care groups can improve overall health and well being, compared to individual visits.

To assess the potential of group visits in comparison to individual visits, a Centering Parenting Model of group well-child care was implemented at a Federally Qualified Health Center in an urban primary care setting designated as Patient-Centered Medical Home.

Study participants are parent-baby dyads and are established patients at the Family Health Center. Centering Parenting groups consisting of 5-10 pairs meet at predefined routine well-child visits to receive routine well baby care in a group setting.

The purpose of this project is to provide group well child care as an alternative to individual provider care with the hope of improving quality outcomes and parent satisfaction.

Cedric Edwards, MD
The Effectiveness of a Mobile Cervical Cancer Screening Program in Andhra Pradesh, India

 Background: Cervical cancer is a completely preventable disease. Yet 470,000 new cases of cervical cancer are diagnosed each year and 300,000 women die annually worldwide. The overwhelming majority of these cervical cancer cases occur in the developing world. Pap smears are the main screening test for cervical cancer but many developing countries lack the infrastructure to perform pap smears. To address this need for cervical cancer screening in the developing world, the medical organization Prevention International: No Cervical Cancer (PINCC) developed a mobile service which screens for precancerous cervical cells using direct visual inspection of the cervix with acetic acid (VIA) and immediately removes suspected lesions in a single visit using either cryotherapy or LEEP. This study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of PINCC’s mobile cervical cancer screening program in Andhra Pradesh, India.

Methods: For 12 days in August and in December 2009, PINCC went to a different village each day in Andhra Pradesh, India. Mobile cervical screening using VIA was performed on non-pregnant, non-menstruating women between the ages of 23 and 75 who did not have signs of vaginitis. Pap smears were often performed for VIA-negative lesions, or if the squamocolumnar junction (SCJ) was not fully visualized because it extended into the cervical os. Biopsies were taken of VIA-positive lesions. Cryotherapy was performed if VIA-positive lesions covered less than 75% of the cervix and there was adequate visualization of the SCJ. Women with VIA-positive lesions covering >75% of the cervix received LEEP. PINCC referred all women suspected of having cervical cancer to the local hospital, based on the screening VIA results and biopsy. These women did not undergo cryotherapy or LEEP treatment.

Results: PINCC screened 623 women for cervical cancer during the 24 days that they were in Andhra Pradesh, India. Cervical samples from only 543 women were used in this study since there were missing data for 80 screened patients. Of the 543 women screened, 431 were VIA-negative and 112 were VIA positive. The VIA-negative group included 391 completely normal cervical screening after adequate visualization of the SCJ and 40 women who had to undergo pap smears for inadequate visualization of the SCJ. Precancerous cervical cells were found in 3 of 40 pap smears. Of the 112 participants with positive VIA lesions, 21% had cryotherapy, 27% had LEEP, and 45% were biopsied only without treatment due to either a non-functional cryotherapy or LEEP. Squamous cell carcinoma was found in 1.3% of the screened women. Of all the 112 VIA-positive lesions seen, biopsies found cancer or precancerous cells in 53 women, for a positive predictive value of 47%.

Conclusions: In 24 days, PINCC effectively screened 543 women with the low-cost method of VIA and immediately treated them with cryotherapy or LEEP. The PPV of VIA to detect precancerous cells was similar to other studies involving VIA. Further measures need to be taken to reduce the number of samples with missing data and to ensure operational equipment. A mobile “see and treat” model is a feasible method to address the high cervical cancer rates in the developing world.

Ross MacDonald, MD:
Montefiore Transitions Clinic: Reaching the Recently Incarcerated

The Montefiore Transitions Clinic (TC) was established to provide access to primary care, mental health services and social services for recently incarcerated adults. In July, 2009, we established a TC for recently incarcerated adults through partnership with Bronx Parole Board and The Osborne Association, a local prisoner advocacy community based organization (CBO). Initially, referrals to TC were primarily from parole officers and the overall burden of chronic illness was low. Here we report on the impact of a community health worker (CHW) on patient recruitment and disease severity.

To evaluate the impact of the referral source on the disease prevalence seen at TC, we performed a retrospective chart review comparing patients seen before and after the CHW was hired. Data was available for the first 39 TC patients, of whom 38 were referred by the Parole Committee, and the 30 most recent TC patients, 29 of whom were referred by the CBO through the CHW. Our primary measure of interest is prevalence of chronic disease in TC patients, including HIV, hepatitis C, mental illness, opioid dependence and diabetes. Secondary measures include time from correctional facility release to first clinic visit and insurance status.

With the assistance of a CHW, the TC has reached a population of former inmates with a higher burden of chronic illness. Referrals from a CBO, coordinated by a community health worker, identified a population with a high prevalence of chronic diseases including HIV, hepatitis C, mental illness and opioid dependence. system of facilitated referrals, along with access to health centers where barriers to care are minimized, can help bridge gaps in care for the formerly incarcerated population.

Shwetha Iyer, MD:
Improving Resident Counseling Competence: Implementing and Evaluating the Impact of a 5A’s skills-based obesity curriculum

Needs and Objectives: Although weight loss can lead to a reduction in diabetes and hypertension and improve health outcomes, only 42% of obese U.S. adults report that their physicians have counseled them about weight loss. Even when weight loss is advised, most physicians do not discuss specific weight loss strategies, indicating that the quality of counseling may be poor. To address this gap, we adapted, implemented, and conducted a pilot evaluation of a previously developed theory-based obesity counseling curriculum for residents using a 5A’s behavioral change model. In this model, residents are trained to assess obesity risk, agree on mutual goals, advise a weight-control program, assist in establishing appropriate intervention, and arrange for follow-up. The objective of our evaluation was to determine the feasibility and impact of a novel obesity counseling curriculum, which incorporates training and practice in obesity counseling skills, on residents’ self-assessed competency in obesity counseling.

Setting and Participants: Our target audience was 28 interns and residents in the Primary Care/Social Internal Medicine Residency Program at Montefiore Medical Center, Bronx, New York.

Description: The curriculum was delivered 4 times over a 6 month period to groups of 5 to 10 residents during ambulatory medicine blocks. One week prior to curriculum participation, residents completed a previously validated survey with 9 items measuring self-assessed obesity counseling competence, based on the 5A’s model. Each question used a 4-point likert scale. The 3-hour 5A’s Obesity Curriculum included a 2-hour didactic and discussion session on the epidemiology of obesity, 5A’s obesity counseling framework and practical tools for its implementation. Case-based discussions of treatment modalities included behavior change, medication, and surgical options for weight loss. The final hour involved reviewing motivational interviewing (MI) and practicing with a standardized patient. Two months after participation, residents completed a post-intervention survey, and gave general feedback. Preliminary analyses compared median scores before and after curriculum participation using the Wilcoxin test.

Evaluation: To date, 16 residents have completed the curriculum and surveys, with another 10 scheduled to participate. Residents reported their counseling competence in: 1) assessing patients’ stage of change, 2) diet and 3) current level of physical activity; 4) agreeing on mutual goals for weight loss; 5) assisting patients in goal setting for weight loss; 6) responding to patients’ questions about behavior change; 7) offering medication and 8 ) surgical weight loss options; and 9) using MI techniques to change behavior. After the curriculum, there was a significant increase in the median scores from 2 to 3 (2=somewhat able to perform, 3=able to perform adequately) in residents’ report of assessing stage of change, assisting in goal setting, discussing treatment options and using MI techniques. There were no differences in the remaining domains. On qualitative questions, residents reported a high degree of satisfaction with the curriculum and requested additional skills practice sessions in MI.

Discussion: We developed and implemented a novel curriculum for residents to address strategies for weight loss using the 5A’s behavior change model, which incorporated obesity counseling skills practice. Preliminary pre and post curricular analyses showed improvements in several areas of residents’ obesity counseling competence. Implementing this three hour curriculum in a residency program was feasible. Post curricular questionnaires indicated that residents were satisfied with the curriculum, and were eager for additional sessions for continued practice and refinement of obesity counseling using MI skills. Further evaluation, with additional learners, and direct observation of counseling skills is needed to fully elucidate the impact of the curriculum in promoting effective obesity counseling skills.

Preetha Iyengar, MD:
Effectiveness of a Brief Health Education Intervention to Address Chronic Malnutrition in Quito, Ecuador

Chronic malnutrition is associated with childhood mortality and affects up to a quarter of children in Ecuador. In southern Quito, lack of knowledge and poor diet diversification are contributing factors. Existing research has shown health education is a critical component in influencing behavioral changes and local collaborators, such as the Ecuadorian Ministry of Health and community physicians, have identified health education as an area that merits further investigation in their patient population. Hence, the objective of our study was to assess the effectiveness of a health education intervention given at a government-run clinic in Quito, Ecuador.

A 20-minute workshop and pictogram handouts were developed to provide education on the effects of protein malnutrition and highlight locally available protein sources. The workshop was offered daily over a 4-week period and the handout was distributed to a subset of patients after the workshop. Oral questionnaires were developed to assess protein nutrition knowledge, confidence in participant’s own knowledge, and protein intake pre- and post-workshop and at home visits three weeks later. A total of 98 participants completed pre- and post-workshop questionnaires and 57 completed home visit questionnaires. We found that knowledge and confidence increased after protein education workshops with retention at home visits. The utilization of pictogram handouts in educational sessions improved protein intake. These findings support continuing to work with Ecuadorian collaborators to further develop one-time, concise educational interventions to improve dietary behavior.

Anjani Reddy, MD: 
Exploring GME Social Accountability

[This presentation won the Daniel Leicht Social Medicine Award and the Chairman's Research Award.]

Purpose: Seen as a public good, graduate medical education (GME) was financed by Medicare 1965, expecting that this responsibility would continue “until the community bears the cost in some other way”. Over 40 years later, Medicare is still bearing the brunt of GME financing, spending $9.5 billion last year. Many have suggested that academic health centers have become dependent on such financing. We sought to better understand the perceived responsibility of GME institutions in addressing the needs of the nation, and the utility of and most likely methods to measure and compare the social impact of GME institutions.

Method: Eighteen informants were interviewed via semi-structured interviews done by phone and in-person. Key informants were chosen from salient national agencies/associations after developing a sampling matrix to ensure appropriate breadth of perspectives. Snowballing technique was employed, and informant interviews were continued until saturation of themes was achieved and confirmed via search for disconfirming data.

Results: Seventeen of eighteen informants noted that GME institutions have a responsibility to be socially accountable. Informants’ definitions of social accountability included: training of future physicians, addressing workforce shortages and providing service to the institution’s community. Multiple informants noted barriers to measuring social accountability, though many informants suggested possible tools for measurement of social accountability.

Conclusions: GME is largely seen as a public good, and multiple informants noted that recipients of GME funding should be responsible to their communities. However, time constraints, financial limitations, and curriculum overload limit GME institutions’ ability to be socially accountable. Financial incentives, accreditation requirements and maintenance of mission values can address GME institutions’ responsibility to medical education, workforce shortages and community service.

Irene Hwang, MD: 
Development of a Longitudinal Curriculum in Correctional Health at RPSM

Prison release rates in New York City correlate directly with poverty rates, and a disproportionate number of prisoners are returning to the Bronx. Recently released individuals attempting to reintegrate into the community are among the most marginalized of populations and have grave health outcomes. RPSM residents provide care for many of these patients who are directly or indirectly impacted by incarceration. The goal of this project was to develop a longitudinal training program in correctional health for family and internal medicine residents. Methods included reviewing existing correctional health training programs, interviews with medical and academic directors, rotations and site visits to correctional facilities and transitions clinics in San Francisco and New York City.

The proposal for a longitudinal correctional health curriculum is comprised of required clinical and didactic components: Transitions Clinic sessions at FHC and CHCC during elective blocks throughout residency as the foundation; health education workshops, targeted outreach and discharge planning at Rikers Island and VCBC; buprenorphine training and case-based discussions with a substance abuse specialist; and cross-track conferences to discuss syllabus readings. Residents interviewed unanimously support a longitudinal model of learning and this proposed curriculum provides an example of a rigorous training program to meet their educational needs.

Ari Kriegsman, MD & Allison Stark, MD, MBA: 
A resident-driven approach to systems-based practice education and innovation at a primary care medicine ambulatory teaching clinic

Description: During the academic year 2010 – 2011 we initiated an iterative educational process to engage residents in a dialogue about SBP. An anonymous web-based survey was sent to all 19 PGY2 and 3 residents asking them how they would handle four common clinical scenarios that occur when the resident is not in clinic or between patients’ clinic visits: (1) following up of critical lab values; (2) scheduling non-routine follow-up appointments; (3) handling urgent care situations when patients call from home; and (4) titrating medications. Each scenario was derived from our clinical experience and piloted with colleagues prior to survey distribution. Results were analyzed and a set of best practices was created. At a program-wide retreat attended by approximately 25 residents and faculty we moderated a two-hour discussion on the survey results, best practices and other SBP topics identified. A second anonymous survey was sent to the same 19 residents assessing the value of monthly SBP meetings.

Evaluation: Seventy-four percent (14/19) of residents responded to the initial survey, with up to 5 solutions given for each scenario. Responses varied by the skill level of the clinic staff member asked to assist with the task, the number of phone calls, emails, and hand-offs required, and the time needed for task completion. Given the heterogeneity of responses a set of best practices, emphasizing non-physician resources, was created and disseminated. Our second survey used a 5-point Likert scale (5=Quite Valuable, 1=No Value) to quantify the value of monthly SBP discussions. One hundred percent (14/14) of responders reported that sessions would be valuables or quite valuable. We then initiated monthly discussions (60-75 minutes) during ambulatory blocks (4-8 residents/month). To date we have held two sessions. Prior to each session we solicit SBP topics and distribute a resident derived agenda. Afterwards, we email key takeaway points and post updates on our program’s searchable website.

Bonnie Stahl, MD: 
Routine Gonorrhea and Chlamydia Screening for Women entering Methadone Mainteance Treatment: Is it worth it?

Background: Chlamydia and gonorrhea (GC) screening in specific populations, including substance users, is recommended. Entry into methadone maintenance treatment presents an opportunity to screen a high risk population, yet the prevalence of Chlamydia and GC infection in this population has not been well-defined. To address this gap, we began to routinely offer screening to women admitted to our Bronx methadone maintenance treatment program (MMTP).

Methods: A chart review of consecutively admitted adult female patients from June 1, 2010 is underway. Using a structured chart review instrument, we abstracted sociodemographics (age, race, income), substance type, injection use, trauma and incarceration history; HIV antibody status, syphilis titer, and urine GC and Chlamydia results.

Results: Forty-nine women were entered treatment between June and December 21, 2010. Eleven (22%) self-identified as Black, 32(65%) as Hispanic. Their mean age was 40 All had heroin dependence. Thirty-one (63%) reported cocaine use. Twenty-two (45%) had injected. Eleven (22%) had experienced domestic violence and 30(61%) had been incarcerated. Nine (18%) were HIV positive, and five (10%) had serologic evidence of syphilis infection. None of the 46 (94%) women tested for GC and Chlamydia were positive.

Conclusions: Although women entering MMTP are typically considered at high risk for sexually transmitted diseases, routine testing GC and Chlamydia testing did not identify any infections. The HIV and syphilis infection rates we found warrant routine screening, but the absence of GC and Chlamydia in this population does not thus far support routine screening with drug use as a sole risk factor.

Asiya S. Tschannerl, MD, MPH, MSc: 
What is a Social Medicine Doctor?

Purpose: It is clear that social conditions contribute to ill health. This was described as early as the 19th century by Rudolf Virchow, generally considered the founder of social medicine. Yet, medical training continues to center on the molecular basis of disease. In efforts to create a different model of physician training, the Residency Program in Social Medicine (RPSM) of Montefiore Hospital was founded in 1970 to train a cadre of socially-minded physicians dedicated to providing care for the underserved. The RPSM is a holistic curriculum that encompasses an understanding of social problems affecting the health of individuals and communities and strategies for addressing these issues, while training in community health centers. This study investigates what encompasses a social medicine physician today, and how their practice differs from other primary care doctors.

Methods: All current residents, faculty and alumni of the Residency Program were eligible to participate in the survey, which was emailed in March 2009. A survey monkey questionnaire was used, and emailed to current department members and an alumni list-serve. The complete survey had seven items that included status (resident, faculty, or alumni); specialty (Family Medicine, Internal Medicine, Pediatrics); questions about the role of social medicine in regards to their practice, how it differs from other primary care doctors, and questions regarding the RPSM curriculum. Demographic data describing the participants was tabulated, and comments were grouped into themes and investigated via textual and qualitative analysis.

Results: The survey was completed by 173 participants. Forty-seven percent were in the field of Family Medicine, 30% in Internal Medicine, and 24% in Pediatrics. Fifty-six percent were alumni, 26% were faculty, and 21% were current residents. There were three main themes that were common to most responses, which were that social medicine doctors 1) have a broad knowledge of the social determinants of health, 2) have the ability to translate this broad knowledge of health into a specific treatment plan, and 3) promote social justice. Within each theme were various sub-themes which provided a richer description of social medicine concepts and its practice contrasted with the practice other primary care physicians.

Conclusions: Social conditions are not separate from medical conditions, an integral concept of social medicine and RPSM. Although this study was limited in that not all potential subjects responded and responses varied greatly in length and description, the concepts of social medicine are clearly central to their practice of medicine. Social medicine is thought to be valuable and essential in the treatment of individuals and communities, and an opportunity for social change. This model of medicine was viewed as fundamentally different from the practice of other primary care physicians. Further research in the practice of social medicine on patient outcomes, and perspectives of patients treated by social medicine doctors could be helpful in substantiating our findings and expanding the number of social medicine residency programs nation-wide.

Feyisara Akanki, MD & Scott Ikeda, MD, MPH:
Staff perceptions of Patient Centered Medical Home implementation in two urban clinics

The Patient Centered Medical Home (PCMH) has received attention as a cost-effective way to address the myriad problems facing the US primary care system. As more practices become PCMH’s, staff must carry out this change, however their perceptions of the PCMH and the change process may not be congruent. We will compare staff opinions of the PCMH transformation at two primary care clinics in the Bronx, NY, using focus groups consisting of providers and support staff, and analyze recorded transcripts for themes. We anticipate the analysis will yield insight into perceptions of the PCMH and the capacities of the clinics to carry out their transformations that will be useful to other practices as they begin their own transformation processes.

Richard Gil, MD:
Screening, brief intervention and referral to treatment (SBIRT) for opioid abuse in an urban hospitalized population: a pilot study

 Numerous studies demonstrate the deleterious health outcomes associated with substance abuse and dependence. To intervene early in the course of substance use, Screening, Brief Intervention, and Referral to Treatment (SBIRT) has been advocated by many.Few studies have examined the feasibility of or outcomes associated with conducting SBIRT in hospitalized patients. Although data regarding SBIRT for drug use has been sparse, with the rise in opioid use, abuse, and dependence, many advocate for SBIRT specifically for drug use. We sought to test the feasibility of conducting SBIRT for problematic opioid use targeting patients hospitalized on the medical wards of a large urban academic medical center.

We identified adult patients who were admitted floors of the medical wards and administered audio computer-assisted self-interviews assessing theirof problematic opioid use using the WHO ASSISTscreening tool.Patients were categorized as having no opioid use, or low, moderate, or high risk of problematic opioid use. Those who had moderate or high risk problematic opioid use received a brief computer-based intervention. We found that 42 (56.0%) reported no opioid use, 4 (5.3%) low risk, 26 (34.7%) moderate risk, and 3 (4.0%) high risk of problematic opioid use. Of the 29 patients with moderate or high risk, 19 (65.5%) were interested in referral to treatment and 27 (93.1%) reported that the brief computerized intervention was useful. We question whether our model of conducting SBIRT-with a dedicated person outside of the team delivering health care-is feasible. However, this urban inpatient population seems at significant risk thus more research is warranted on how to best use SBIRT to intervene on problematic opioid users in the inpatient setting.

Harini Kumar, MD
Making Exercise a Reality: Zumba Bronx

Zumba Bronx is a reproducible and sustainable form of dance exercise that is built on one of the strengths of an underserved community, the passion to dance. Dance aerobic exercise has been shown to improve participants’ s BMI. The 2010 ADA noted that a 5-10% decrease in weight translates into a decrease in HbA1c. The literature review indicated that successful programs for weight loss have consolidated exercise, diet, and behavior modification plans. In addition, studies have illustrated the utilization of pedometers as a useful tool to motivate diabetic patients to increase physical activity and maintain these efforts. The goal of this social medicine project is to promote physical activity for patients with diabetes at the Williamsbridge Family Practice. The study will utilize this culturally appropriate, and cost-effective form of dance exercise, Zumba, coupled with pedometers, and develop patient centered support that can be incorporated into the FHC and CHCC health centers in the future. The objective of this project is to provide diabetic patients with the tools to develop and maintain a healthy lifestyle.

Anna E. Jackson, MD
Retention and Screening of Immigrant Patients in the South Bronx

The purpose of this study was to evaluate whether a dedicated immigrant health session within a larger primary care practice can achieve retention in and quality of health care for immigrants. This was a retrospective cohort study with medical record review of all new patients seen at the OPEN-IT clinic at CHCC from October 1, 2007 to September 30, 2009. The primary outcome was retention in care, defined as at least one follow-up visit within one year after the initial visit. Secondary outcomes included rates of age-appropriate cancer screenings and results of specific screening tests as recommended by the CDC for refugee populations, including Hepatitis B surface antigen, tuberculin skin test, complete blood count, and ova and parasites in stool. Results showed that 79% of patients were retained in care, with no detected difference in retention based on age, gender, length of time in US, or presence of chronic illness. Rates of mammography and cervical cancer screening were 82% and 79% respectively, but the rate of age-appropriate colorectal cancer screening was only 24%. We also found that over a quarter of patients screened had evidence of latent tuberculosis, anemia, and intestinal parasites, although our numbers were small. Our results support the need for clear recommendations regarding immigrant-specific screening. Further work needs to be done to improve rates of colorectal cancer screening within our model and to better understand which diseases need to be screened for in the immigrant population.

Justin Sanders, MD, MSc
Meanings in Methadone:Perceptions About Methadone Doses Among Individuals in Methadone Maintenance Treatment.

Medicines have meaning and these meanings affect both their efficacy and their perception of it. Perceptions about efficacy affect adherence to and retention in treatment. Observations by substance abuse clinicians suggest that patients in methadone maintenance treatment(MMT)hold perceptions about methadone and methadone doses that may not reflect current medical understanding about methadone, including about interactions and adverse effects. Literature about the experience of patients in MMT is sparse, and this study aims to understand the experience with and perceptions about methadone among patients in an urban methadone clinic. Individuals in substance abuse treatment are a marginalized population. It is anticipated that a better understanding of their experience in a particularly stigmatized realm of medical treatment will allow clinicians to better understand their needs, their response to treatments with potential for interaction to methadone, and thereby improve the adherence to and retention in methadone treatment.

April Wilson , MD & Lin-Fan Wang, MD
Perspectives on reproductive healthcare access among homeless female adolescents living in family shelters in the Bronx

 Homeless adolescents experience multiple barriers to contraceptive use and they have high rates of unintended pregnancy and poor birth outcomes. The goal is to conduct semi-structured interviews with homeless female adolescents ages 14-18 at family shelters in the Bronx and to have teen educational seminars at a homeless family shelter. Interviews include questions on demographic data and open-ended questions regarding beliefs about contraception, experiences with accessing reproductive healthcare, future plans, and specific barriers to accessing reproductive healthcare as an adolescent living in a family shelter. Teen seminars focus on pregnancy, sex, and STDs. The purpose of our study is to 1) describe the experience of unintended pregnancy, abortion, and contraceptive use; 2) identify barriers to reproductive healthcare access including contraception; and 3) describe preferences for reproductive healthcare access in homeless teens. This data will generate data for targeted changes in services.

Jason Beste, MD
The Use of Traditional Botanicals among Pregnant Women in Rwanda

 A survey of pregnant Rwandan women’s use of complementary medicine.

 

Register now for Doctors for Global Health 2010 Annual Meeting

1 Comment

Doctors for Global Health will be holding its 16th Annual General Assembly from July 29th to the 31st at Loyola Marymount University in California.  You can register now at: http://www.dghonline.org. The People’s Health Movement (PHM)/USA circle will be holding a pre-conference meeting in the days preceding the conference.

The theme of the Assembly is Community Action for Health and Social Justice: Health Begins Where We Work, Live, and Play.  Here is a synopsis of the Program:

Keynote Speakers: America Bracho and Theresa & Blase Bonpane

Dr. America Bracho is the Executive Director of Latino Health Access a community health center in Orange County, California.  She was the subject of a 2009 profile by Bill Moyers which discusses her work as a community organizer.

Theresa and Blase Bonpane are founders of Office of The Americas, an educational group dedicated to furthering the cause of justice and peace in the hemisphere.  The Office sponsor a weekly radio program on KPFK (Los Angeles) called World Focus.

Panel discussions:

Health and Human Rights of Migrant Communities

  • Steven Wallace, PhD- UCLA Center for Health Policy Research
  • Kyrsten Sinema- Arizona State House of Representatives
  • DREAM Act students
  • Irma Cruz Nava, MD- CEPAFOS, Oaxaca, Mexico
  • Samaritans Patrol of Arizona

The Right to Food and Food Justice:

  • Anuradha Mittal- Executive Director of the Oakland Institute
  • Anje Van Berckelaer, MD- Robert Wood Johnson Clinical Scholar
  • (others TBA)

Other activities:

  • Tour of Father Greg Boyle’s Homeboy Industries and Skid Row
  • Physicians for Social Responsibility discussion on nuclear technology
  • Update on People’s Health Movement-USA
  • Lively conversations, networking, socializing, and music
  • Updates from DGH partner communities in Mexico, El Salvador, Peru, Guatemala, Sierra Leone, Uganda, and Burundi.

EARLY BIRD REGISTRATION PRIOR TO JUNE 1ST. SCHOLARSHIPS AVAILABLE FOR STUDENTS AND ANYONE WITH NEED!

Please register now at www.dghonline.org

posted by Matt Anderson

Barriers to Accessing Health Care for Asians: From the Bronx to Cuba

1 Comment

For 20 years Joyce Wong, a friend and colleague, has worked as a licensed clinical social worker  with the Cambodian and Vietnamese refugee community in the Bronx.  We wanted to share with readers of the Portal some of her recent work examining immigrant health care both in the Bronx and in Cuba.

Throughout the years she has been involved in training medical residents and students on refugee mental health in addition to organizing with the Committee Against Anti-Asian Violence (now called Organizing Asian Communities)  in the area of language rights for the Southeast Asian community. She contributed a chapter, on the mental health and resiliency of elderly Chinese  men in Cuba, to the book Community Health Care in Cuba. She is a native New Yorker who grew up in Washington Heights to parents from Puerto Rico and China.

Accessing Health Care: From the Bronx to Cuba

In 2010, Ms. Wong was interviewed for Asia-Pacific Forum, a program on New York radio  station WBAI.  The interview (available at this link) examined barriers to health care access for two different Asian immigrant communities. The first was the Southeast Asian refugee community in the Bronx who have faced challenges to obtaining language access and quality health/mental health care.  (See our prior posts on the Justice is Healing campaign). She then turned to Cuba where she shared her research on health access for the Chinese-Cuban elderly male population in Havana.

La Magia de Cuba

During her visits to Cuba for the book chapter, Ms. Wong produced a short photo-video documentary entitled La Magia de Cuba, for a course on global mental health at the Harvard Program in Refugee Trauma on healing environments. It needs no commentary or introduction. Enjoy:

Ms. Wong is planning to return to Cuba this year to expand her research on elderly Chinese men with a plan to publish a book with Professor Eric Tang, University of Texas.  A fundraising event will take place  later this spring and we will keep readers informed.  She can be reached via email.

posted by Matt Anderson

A visit & lunch at the Chieu Kien Buddhist Temple

4 Comments

Phuc Kien Temple in the BronxLast Sunday Social Medicine Rounds took place at the Chieu Kien Buddhist Temple located at 2011 Clinton Avenue, a few blocks southwest of the Bronx Zoo.  For those who do not know the neighborhood, the Temple was easy to miss, particularly given the fierce rainstorm outside. It occupies a nondescript building across from a big apartment complex. The front door is almost completely obscured by an iron gate. Indeed the only visible sign that this a temple is a yellow circle above the door with a pink lotus flower in the center.

Coming in from the storm we were greeted by Dr. Thoai Lien who had been expecting us and would be our host.  Dr. Lien informed us that he was an organic chemist and had worked for several years at a pharmaceutical company investigating medical plants.  We learned from him that there were two Vietnamese Buddhist Temples in the Bronx, the Chieu Kien Temple and the Chua Thap Phuong temple located at 2222 Andrews Ave. [There is also a Cambodian Buddhist Temple run by the Khmer Buddhist Society at 2738 Marion Avenue.]

The temple was buzzing with activity as people came and out from the storm.  At the other end of the entrance hall the monk was giving a sermon in Vietnamese in the main shrine; this was broadcast throughout the building.  Dr. Lien noted that during the Lunar New Year the Temple had hosted three days of celebrations and over 800 people had visited.  As soon as our group had assembled, Dr. Lien took us down to the basement where a dozen women were busy preparing food in a tiny kitchen. Half of the basement had been covered into a dining room and we sat down at one of dozen or so plastic tables.  It was time for lunch.

As hot tea and food began to arrive at our table, Dr. Lien explained to us that the Temple had been founded in 2002 by members of the community. They combined donations for a down payment on the property, not entirely sure how they would pay the mortgage.  But they had found a monk, the Reverend Thich Thien Chi, to live in the Temple and had faith things would work out.  Their faith was justified and the Temple had become so popular that they had already paid off the mortgage.  “The Temple belongs to all of us,” he said with evident pride.

The secret to the Temple’s success may lie – in some measure – in Reverend Thien Chi’s unusual talents as a cook.  During the week he prepares food for the weekend.  On Saturdays and Sundays the parishioners warm and serve the food while he gives his sermon and then leads meditation and chants. Dr. Lien emphasized that all the food is given away. Reverend Thien Chi’s philosophy is that by serving vegetarian food, he is keeping people from killing animals and thus spreads good in the world.

The result of all the cooking was a dining room filled with children running about, teenagers with iPods plugged in their ears, and adults of all ages.  There is certainly no denying that the food was excellent.  Over healthy portion of rice we had spring rolls, roasted bean curd, mixed vegetables, and finally no less than three deserts. The desserts apparently were brought by the parishioners and included one custard created from coconut and mung bean.  There is no doubt that feeding people and eating together creates a sense of community.

While we ate, Dr. Lien shared a bit of his personal story. He had stayed in Vietnam for three years after the collapse of the Saigon government in April 1975, while he was in his final year in High School. In 1978 he arrived in the US sponsored by someone in Arkansas. He wanted to go to the University but knew that his English was not that good. He got a job and enrolled part time at a local community college.  He managed to accumulate 68 credits and an excellent academic record. He also benefitted from generous educational benefits for refugees so that he was able to enroll at Columbia University in 1981, graduating with a Ph.D. in organic chemistry. He subsequently went to work for a large pharmaceutical company in Boston but continued to commute back and forth to the Bronx regularly, serving voluntarily as a substitute teacher in the Temple’s Vietnamese language school.

After eating we had a brief tour of the rest of the temple. Services were over so we took off our shoes and entered the main shrine dominated by a large golden Buddha. Behind it was a small room where members of the temple could come and leave the ashes of their relatives.  People were praying here and leaving offerings of fruit and incense.  The wall was covered with photographs of the departed, people of all ages. Down the hall was a private space for the monk and a room where people were praying to “the Goddess.” Upstairs was a happy pandemonium of children just let out from Vietnamese class.  Finally we visited the small garden next to the temple where a smaller shrine was dedicated to storing the ashes of the deceased.  Despite the grey weather this was a lovely spot.

Dr. Lien & Dr. Vanessa Pratomo (DFSM)

As we said good-bye, Dr. Lien told us his dream of creating a nursing home for the community.  He did not want the elderly to be alone at home. He also shared with us that he was a writer; he had, in fact, written a poem about the monk. He shared a story he had written (in English) in the Nguoi Dep Magazine entitled “A Poor Scholar named Hai-Thoai.”  It recounts a tale told to Dr. Lien by his grandfather in which a poor scholar is rewarded for his chastity by aquiring the ability to exorcise spirits; he also marries a princess! The story ends: “In this terrestrial life, if you do things justly, your good deeds will be properly credited. Don’t ever think God is too far away to do you some justice.  He can be by your side if you deserve His help.” This seemed an appropriate thought for a Temple that seems to give so much to so many.

[The original version of this posting contained several inaccuracies. This is a corrected version.]

posted by Matt Anderson

Community Health Care in Cuba

Add a comment

On September 27th 2009, Dr. Joan Beder, Dr. Susan Mason, and Joyce Wong, CSW spoke at Social Medicine Rounds on Community Health Care in Cuba. Drs. Beder and Mason have recently published a book of the same title which we have reviewed on the Portal (see: New Book on the Cuban Health Care System).

Breast Cancer in Cuba

IMG_0537Dr. Joan Beder began with a discussion of her work with breast cancer patients. Dr. Beder is a professor of social work at the Wurzweiler School of Social Work at Yeshiva University. She has an interest in oncology services and specifically services for women with breast cancer. She began her talk by pointing out some of the contradictory aspects of work in Cuba. Cubans have guaranteed rights to health and education; this something that we did not have in the US. Yet it was clear walking around Havana that Cuba is  an impoverished country where food was rationed.

Dr. Beder noted that the Cuban system provided essentially the same treatment options – chemotherapy, radiation, and surgery – that were available to patients in the US. But the supply of drugs was quite limited. Breast cancer screening programs had been impacted by the US trade embargo; the Cubans could not obtain the best mammography film and equipment because it was produced in the US. As a consequence higher than necessary doses of radiation were used in mammography.

Dr. Beder was asked by the  Cubans to provide some guidance on helping women with the psychosocial consequences of breast cancer. She worked with the Federation of Cuban Women which runs a series of Women’s Centers where breast self-examination and mammography are promoted. Initially they considered setting up a self-help hotline for breast cancer survivors. This turned out to be problematic due to the deficiencies of the Cuban system; people may not always have access to a phone in a private setting.  Her work led her to undertake a training program  in the special needs of oncology patients for Cuban social workers.

She concluded by pointing out that cancer is now the second leading cause of death in Cuba; cardiovascular disease is number one. Cognizant of this, the Ministry of Health has begun a special national program to train doctors in the prevention and early detection of cancer.

Schizophrenia and Mental Illness

Susan Mason teachingDr. Susan E. Mason is also a professor of social work at Yeshiva University; in addition she is  a professor of sociology and the chair of the college departments of sociology and political science. Her area of expertise is schizophrenia and she is the co-author of Diagnosis Schizophrenia: A Comprehensive Resource for Patients, Families, and Professionals, a fascinating book which uses patient stories to describe what it is like to have schizophrenia.

The Cuban approach to mental illness also has been shaped by a context where resources are limited and medications are in short supply; again, this is due – in part – to the effects of the embargo. Psychosocial treatments have been emphasized and mental health is based on three principles: community, prevention, integration. Arts and music programs are valued and accepted as mental health interventions. She described with a mixture of amusement and admiration how official meetings might be interrupted for a short break allowing the participants (“even the Ministers”) a chance to sing and dance. (It was later suggested that this would be a great idea for hospital rounds).

Care for mentally ill patients was often provided by social workers who live in the same community as the patient and make house calls as needed. When patients needed more supervision, family members were paid to stay at home and care for them. When a family member was not available, patients were placed in a foster home.  Since family members (or foster families) were paid, patients with mental illness were not typically viewed as an economic burden for their family or community.  Dr. Mason shared some pictures of a day program run from a private home. The atmosphere was quite domestic and she remarked: “It feels like you just want to hang out there.”

Did this model work? Dr. Mason expressed frustration that despite the theoretical advantages of this community model for psychiatric care, there was really no hard outcomes data to demonstrate that it was effective.

A Healing Environment

joyce wongJoyce Wong is a social worker at a Bronx community health center where she works primarily with South East Asian immigrants. She grew up in Washington Heights in a community that was largely Cuban and later traveled to Cuba to visit Havana’s Chinatown. This had once been one of the largest “Chinatowns” in the Western Hemisphere. With emigration, the population has dwindled considerably and now consisted primarily of the elderly.

In Chinatown, she interviewed elderly men to learn how they had managed to survive in Cuba after leaving their homes in China. She found the men relied on ethnic pride and identity, maintaining their language, and consciously suppressing painful memories. She described this not as a form of repression, but rather as a conscious decision to look for happiness and self-healing.

Ms. Wong made a short film about her trips to Cuba, a place she felt was a “healing environment.” La Magia de Cuba (Cuba’s Magic) is a montage of music and photos and is available on Picasa at this  link.

Thoughts

To read more about this work, please consult Drs. Mason and Beder’s book: Community health care in Cuba.

The situation of Cuban patients, denied access to the best possible care because of the US trade embargo was denounced by Amnesty International in September. Readers interested in learning about the health impacts of the embargo should consult their report: The US Embargo against Cuba: Its Impact on Economic and Social Rights.

posted by Matt Anderson, MD

Senators introduce legislation to protect immigrant detainees

Add a comment

courtesy of wespennest on flickr.com

courtesy of wespennest on flickr.com

Daphne Eviatar of the The Washington Independent reported last week on a new piece of legislation designed in response to growing awareness about the poor and even dangerous conditions experienced by detainees held by the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) Agency (see original article here).

New York Senator Kirsten Gillebrand, along with Senators Kennedy (D-MA) and Menendez (D-NJ) introduced the “Protect Citizens from Unlawful Detention Act” and the “Prevent Detainee Deaths and Abuse Act”, which would increase government accountability towards suspected undocumented immigrants and protect those already detained. The article cites the recent work of Amnesty International USA, the InterAmerican Commission on Human Rights, the National Immigration Law Center and others in documenting the abuses experienced by detainees.

Media attention on the subject has grown. Recently, the NY Times reported on the death of a detainee at a detention center in a Monmouth County detention facility.  Ahmad Tanveer, a Pakistani New Yorker died after exhibiting symptoms consistent with a myocardial infarction (or heart attack). His death would have gone unreported were it not for a scrawled note of another detainee sent to a group who regularly correspond with these individuals. It is still unknown as to why Mr. Tanveer was detained in the first place.

In late July, the Times also reported on a series of three-day hunger-strikes being conducted by immigrant detainees in an ICE facility in Louisana. These men are protesting poor conditions: ”’There are rats, mosquitoes, flies, and spiders inside the cell and inside the dorm. The ventilation is terrible,” [one detainee] said. ‘We have tried to complain about all of these problems, and we haven’t gotten anywhere. They tell us, ‘It’s a jail. This is how it is.””

Immigrant detention affects the communities we serve.  I met an elderly women in clinic recently whose symptoms of sleeplessness and anxiety were exacerbated by the recent detention of her oldest son, in his 40s, the father of her five grandchildren. He had been raised in the U.S. since the age of 10 and had been placed in detention after violating parole in relation to an arrest for Marijuana-related drug charges. He was described by his mother as the family’s main support person, both financially and emotionally. Further complicating his detention is a severe acquired hearing deficiency requiring hearing aids for which he had been recently fitted, but had not yet received.

The Social Medicine portal has reported on this subject before (Homer Venters (RPSM IM 2007) On Immigration Detainee Health Care, July 2008; Persistent Concerns over the Health of Immigrant Detainees, April 2009). It is encouraging that the problems outlined in those two articles is being brought to light and addressed by politicians at the national level. Physicians will have to play a role in enforcing new standards of healthcare in ICE facilities.

In the meantime, call your Senators and ask them to support this valuable piece of legislation.

Free Legal Services for Vietnamese & Cambodian Immigrants in the Bronx

Add a comment

As a follow-up to our post last month on the Justice is Healing Campaign we were asked by community organizer Minh Ha Nguyen to post this information about free legal services available to Cambodian and Vietnamese immigrants living in the Bronx.

Clipboard01CAAAV and NMCIR-Bronx Project have partnered to provide FREE

Immigration Consultation
US Citizenship Application
Low-cost Adjustment of Status
Low-cost Family-based Petitions

Where: CAAAV  Office, 2473 Valentine Ave.
(Fordham Rd. at 188th St.), Bronx, NY 10458
(Available by the BX 12 bus)
When:    Last Wednesday of every Month
(July: Wed 28th, August: Wed 26th, Sep Wed 30th)
Time:  10 am- 2pm
Email: ylp@caaav.org
Phone: (718) 220-7391 ext.16,

For Vietnamese: Minh-Hà, For Khmer: Chhaya

Please note that if you are at least 50 years old and have lived in the US as a legal permanent resident for 20 years or if you are at least 55 years old and have lived in the US as a legal permanent resident for 15 years you are eligible to take the Citizenship Exam in your native language and the exam is oral – not written

CAAAV kết hợp NMCIR-Bronx Project
cung cấp dịch vụ
FREE- miễn phí
về
Tư vấn Luật Di trú
Hồ sơ xin Nhập Tịch
Hồ sơ xin Thẻ Xanh (lệ phí thấp)
Hồ sơ xin Bảo Lãnh Thân Nhân (lệ phí thấp)
Địa điểm:    Văn phòng CAAAV
2473 Valentine Ave.
(Fordham Rd. và 188th St.), bus Bx12
Bronx, NY 10458
Thời gian:    Thứ Tư cuối cùng mỗi tháng
(Tháng 7: ngày 29, Tháng 8: ngày 26, Tháng 9: ngày 30)
10:00 sáng – 2:00 chiều
Email: ylp@caaav.org
Phone: (718) 220-7391 ext.16
Tiếng Việt: Minh-Hà  Tiếng Khmer: Chhaya

posted by Matt Anderson, MD

Documentary on South East Asian Health Organizing in the Bronx: June 18, 2009

1 Comment

img_ylp_04_smThe following letter is from Chhaya Chhoum one of the organizers of the Justice is Healing campaign, an outgrowth of work by Organizing Asian Communities (formerly the Committee Against Anti-Asian Violence):

I want to share some victories we recently had in our Southeast Asian Health Justice Campaign and invite you to a screening of a documentary our Southeast Asian youth made using the theme of justice is healing. Their documentary will be screened as part of the Global Action Project’s end of the year screening on June 18.

We launched the Southeast Asian Health Justice Campaign in 2007 for improved and quality health services at Montefiore Medical Center, a Bronx-based hospital frequented by local Cambodian and Vietnamese refugee communities who continue to suffer from traumas of war and genocide experienced two decades ago from their homelands. Despite the high population of Southeast Asian patients at Montefiore, lack of translation services and cultural competency and the failure of medical staff to link the community’s prevailing health conditions to traumas experienced two decades ago, have led to inadequate provision of health care. Our demands include quality translation services; holistic care that includes alternative treatments, like acupuncture; integration of social services into the health care delivery; cultural competency of medical staff; and increased community outreach and education. Our Southeast Asian youth have been leading this campaign by organizing the community, mobilizing a broad-based support from different sectors, including elected officials, and engaging Montefiore staff for improved health care delivery.

We recently has a victory in the health justice campaign with Montefiore Medical Center hiring a Vietnamese speaking doctor and providing acupuncture free of charge at one of the clinics! While this is a huge victory, we will continue to organize until other important services, such as translation, are implemented. Thank you for all the support that people have given to us that made this victory possible!!

As part of the campaign, three of our youth members participated in the Global Action Project’s documentary making project to document the Southeast Asian community’s health conditions. Please join us in the screening on *June 18, 2009 at 5pm.*

Featuring youth-produced media exploring the impact of racism on self image, the criminalization of immigrant communities, LGBTQ youth responding to hate violence, the work of youth organizers in the Bronx Southeast Asian community and much more!

This event is FREE and open to the community.
Please come support GAP’s youth producers!

5PM – 8PM
JUNE 18, 2009
66 W 12th Street
Tishman Auditorium
at The New School

The Tishman Auditorium is located at 66 W 12th Street, between 5th and 6th Aves
Directions: Take the 4, 5, 6, L, N, Q, R, W to 14th St Union Square, the F, L, V to 6th Ave – 14th St, or the 1,2,3 to 7th Ave – 14 St

RSVP to media@global-action.org <mailto:media@global-action.org>

Also look out for us on these media outlet in the next few months….

Free Speech Radio News, which is broadcast nationally on the Pacifica
network

hyphenmagazine.com/gethyphen

Peace

Chhaya Chhoum


Chhaya Chhoum
YLP, Program Director
CAAAV Organizing Asian Communities
2473 Valentine Ave. Bronx, NY 10458
Ph. 718.220.7391 ext. 15
cya@caaav.org
chhaya4178@gmail.com
www.caaav.org

Persistent Concerns over the Health of Immigration Detainees

2 Comments
Rev. Joseph Danticat (left) died in Immigration Detention

Rev. Joseph Danticat died in Immigration Detention. Shown here with his wife & niece Edwidge

In July of last year we wrote about the activites of RPSM alumni Dr. Homer Venters to bring attention to the medical conditions in the detention facilities of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).  Two reports issued in March – one from Human Rights Watch and the other from the Florida Immigrant Advocacy Center - provide further evidence that ICE is not adequately caring for those in its custody.

A bit of context

To understand the health problems in ICE facilities it is necessary to have some sense of the massive growth in ICE’s detention operations.  In March of this year Amnesty International USA produced a report on ICE entitled Jailed without Justice which notes:

More than 300,000 men, women and children are detained by US immigration authorities each year. They include asylum seekers, torture survivors, victims of human trafficking, longtime lawful permanent residents, and the parents of US citizen children. The use of detention as a tool to combat unauthorized migration falls short of international human rights law, which contains a clear presumption against detention. Everyone has the right to liberty, freedom of movement, and the right not to be arbitrarily detained.

According to the ICE website the average daily number of “detained aliens” in custody rose from 20,838 in 2002-2005 to 31,2345 in 2008 (fiscal years).  By contrast the Amnesty reports notes that as recently as 1996 the immigration system had the capacity to detain only 10,000 people a day.  While the absolute numbers of detainees has increased, ICE has also decreased time each detainee spends in custody.  The result is a massive machine to detain and incarcerate.

It is important to remember that the vast majority of those detained are not criminals.  Those who are in the US without authorization have committed a civil violation not a crime.  In the language of ICE they are “deportable aliens.”  As Human Rights Watch notes it is precisely their status as civil – and not criminal – detainees that deprives them of their right to a lawyer.

In fact, many of those detained are victims of crime themselves.  In July of last year our journal, Social Medicine, published an interview with Victor Toro, an immigration activist in the Bronx.  Victor, who had been severely tortured in Pinochet’s Chile, described his experience with ICE detention:

On 6 July of 2007, when I was traveling from California to New York in an Amtrak train, when we had just passed the city of Buffalo, in one of the stations, the Immigration service entered the train with dogs producing great alarm and upsetting the English-speaking passengers, asking for papers from everyone and acting especially rude and hateful toward the persons who had Hispanic features or looked as if they were from some other part of the world than the USA. I was among these persons, among them I was traveling and had lived nearly 25 years in this country. Without many questions I was hand-cuffed and forced with blows from the train, then handcuffed to the others and taken to the regional immigration offices, afterwards to the Cayuga jail, where I was stripped and forced to wear the orange prison jump-suits, which are the same that everyone in the world saw on the prisoners tortured and tied-up in Guantanamo and Abu Ghraib. This squeezed and cramped all the fibers and vibrations of my body, it took me immediately to sessions of torture and mistreatment that I lived through in Chile, in the torture centers and the concentration camps of Pinochet. It was horrible, I cannot even talk about it and just thinking about and seeing the photos of the prisoners in Guantanamo converted into animals by the authorities of the United States, this has no name. It is pure savageness, a total lack of humanity.

Concerns about immigrant health care

Given the rapid expansion of the ICE facilities it is not surprising that health problems have arisen. Indeed the Inspector General of the Department of Homeland Security had issued a report in December of 2006 noting “instances of non-compliance at four of the five detention facilities, including timely initial and responsive medical care.” Among other concerns the Inspector noted that procedures did not exist for detainees to report abuse or human rights violations.

During May of 2008 the poor care provided in ICE facilities was highlighted in a series of articles in the Washington Post entitled: Careless Detention:  Medical Care in Immigrant Prisons.  This report drew an angry response from ICE and a careful rebutal by the Washington Post’s Ombudsman.

In November of last year the ICE issued a fact sheet on Detainee Health Care which stated that detainees received care for both acute and chronic medical conditions in accordance with community standards.  Further ICE claimed that health care in its facilities was evaluated using “applicable health care standards from the American Correctional Association (ACA), the National Commission on Correctional Health Care (NCCHC), the Joint Commission, and the ICE National Detention Standards to evaluate the care provided to detainees.”

The reports by Human Rights Watch and the Florida Immigrant Advocacy Center paint a very different picture.

Detained and Dismissed

Detained and Dismissed:Women’s Struggles to Obtain Health Care in United States Immigration Detention is the title of the report by Human Rights Watch. It is based on a series of interviews & detention facility visits conducted in 2008.  The interviewees included 48 women who were either in an ICE facility at the time or had been in the past.  The report began by noting that the standards for medical care adopted by ICE were problematic:

Official ICE policy, which focuses on emergency care and keeping the individuals in its custody in deportable condition, effectively discourages the routine provision of some basic women’s health services. ICE’s Division of Immigration Health Services (DIHS) has chief responsibility for the medical care provided to detained immigrants, whether it provides those services directly or through a contractor at a local facility. The DIHS Medical Dental Detainee Covered Services Package, which governs access to off-site specialists, says that requests for non-emergency care will be considered if going without treatment in custody would “cause deterioration of the detainee’s health or uncontrolled suffering affecting his/her deportation status.” Although, on occasion, officials have offered generous interpretations of this policy in its defense, the message about the scope of care provided remains clear. “We are in the deportation business…. Obviously, our goal is to remove individuals ordered removed from our country,” ICE spokesperson Kelly Nantel told a reporter in June 2008. “We address their health care issues to make sure they are medically able to travel and medically able to return to their country.”

As Human Rights Watch notes, the decision by the US government to deprive someone of their liberty means the government is responsible for their care.

The report documented numerous violations of humane treatment:

  • We met women who were denied gynecological care or obtained it only after many requests, including a woman who entered detention shortly after receiving news of an abnormal Pap smear. She told detention authorities that her doctor instructed her to get Pap smears every six months, but after 16 months in detention and many requests, she had still not gotten a Pap smear.
  • We met women who complained of inadequate care during pregnancy, including one diagnosed with an ovarian cyst threatening her five-month pregnancy shortly before she was detained. Her doctor said the cyst should be monitored every two to three weeks, but during her stay in detention of more than four weeks, she was never able to see a doctor. The medical staff’s response to her last sick call request read, “be patient.”
  • We met women who had to beg, plead, and in some cases work within the facility just to get enough sanitary pads not to bleed through their clothes, and one woman who sat on a toilet for hours when the facility would not give her the pads she needed.

The report concluded with a series of specific recommendations.

Dying for Decent Care

Dying for Decent Care: Bad Medicine in Immigration Custody was released in February by the Florida Immigrant Advocacy Center.  It begins with the story of Reverend Joseph Dantica (actually Danticat) who is one of more than 80 people who have died in immigration detention.

Rev. Joseph Dantica, an 81-year-old Baptist minister, fled Haiti after he was targeted for persecution. Gangs had burned and ransacked his home and church. Although Rev. Dantica had a valid visa to enter the United States, where he had traveled many times, he was detained at the Miami airport when he told officials he sought political asylum. At the Krome immigration detention center, he was accused of “faking” his illness and later transferred to the prison ward of Miami’s public hospital in leg restraints. Rev. Dantica died there alone five days after his arrival in October 2004. His family was allowed to see him only after his death.

Danticat’s case gained some public attention from the efforts of his niece Edwidge Danticat, a well-known novelist.

FIAC provides free legal services to detainees in Florida. The organization is, therefore, exposed to the realities of life inside the ICE facilities in Florida. The report provides detailed information on the following health issues:

  • Deaths in Detention
  • Abuses in Medical Care
  • Unacceptable Mental Health Care
  • Physcially Disabled Detainees
  • Mismanaged Medication
  • Forcible drugging to depart
  • Language barriers
  • Unhealthy living conditions
  • Detainees treated like criminals
  • Denied medical records
This report closes with a set of specific recommendations.  Among these are that independent, external scrutiny needs to be exercised over the work of ICE.

Commentary

Deportable aliens are not criminals and alternatives to incarcerations should be fully utilized before we deprive someone of their liberty. Once someone is incarcerated they should receive humane treatment.   ICE’s report of last December seems to say that “everything’s ok.”  This is perhaps the most concerning part of the story and justifies FIAC’s claim that in an oversight vacuum “ICE tolerates a culture of cruelty and indifference to human suffering.”
posted by Matt Anderson, MD

Human Rights Training for Physicians and Mental Health Professionals

Add a comment

logoHealthRight International (formerly Doctors of the World-USA) – https://www.healthright.org/ – offers Human Rights Clinic training sessions for licensed physicians and mental health professionals interested in evaluating torture survivors. The sessions provide volunteers with an understanding of the asylum process in the United States, prepare them to evaluate the effects of torture on survivors, and address the importance of writing effective affidavits. The next session is on Saturday, March 14, 2009 from 8:30 to 1PM. For further information or to register, please contact Lisa Matos Jimenez at lisa.matos@healthright.org or 212-584-4866. The training will take place at HealthRight, 80 Maiden Lane, 6th Fl, NY, NY 10038.
These sessions are offered periodically and interested professionals should consult the HealthRight Interntional website for the most current events -https://www.healthright.org/jobs/volunteers-nyarea.

Commentary:

HealthRight International collaborates with the Human Rights Clinic at the Montefiore Comprehensive Health Care Center.   Their evaluation protocols are quite detailed and adopt a holistic approach, evaluating both physical and psychological sequelae of  torture.  This is excellent training for individuals who work with refugees.

posted by Matt Anderson, MD




Open